For any Marylander, a perfect summer meal undoubtedly includes blue crabs, corn on the cob, and now Mouth Party Old Bay caramels. If youâ€™re not from Maryland, you just may not understand. You see, in Maryland, Old Bay is to cooking what fuel is to a car. This spice of celery salt, pepper and paprika is incorporated into our original caramel ingredients making your taste buds tingle. If you must knowâ€¦. heavy cream, butter, sugar, corn syrup, vanilla, and Old Bay ® seasoning.